1982-1983  

Robert Allen, Grand Valley State College 

1983-1984 

Frank Flagstead, Northwood Institute 

1984-1985

Layne Brower, Ferris State College  

1985-1986

Dan Davis, Calvin College  

1985-1986 

Reggie Fox, University of Wyoming 

1986-1987  

Scott Carlson, Calvin College  

1986-1987 

Tim Perry, Lake Superior State College  

1986-1987 

Clark Plichta, Nazareth College 

1987-1988  

Bill Lynn, Nazareth College 

1988-1989 

Todd Bayle, Grand Rapids Baptist College

1988-1989

Tim Craig, Judson 

1989-1990

Brad Richards, Grand Rapids Baptist College  

1989-1990  

Duane Shears, Indiana-Purdue at Fort Wayne  

1989-1990  

Shannon Swartz, Wayne State  

1989-1990 

Scotty Townsend, Indiana-Purdue at Fort Wayne

1990-1991  

Scot Southland, University of Arizona (Football)

1991-1992

Todd VandenHeuvel, Aquinas College (Baseball) 

1992-1993

Craig Alexander, Tiffin University 

1993-1994 

Ed Canning, Northern Michigan University 

1993-1994

Phill Hoeker, Spring Arbor  

1993-1994  

Eddie Purnell, Ferris State University 

1994-1995 

Keith Guy, Ferris State University  

1995-1996

Mark Reed, LeMoyne University 

1997-1998  

Tony Jasick, Alma College 

1997-1998  

Matt Smith, Lake Superior State University 

1999-2000

Matt Shepherd, Indiana-Purdue at  Fort Wayne 

2000-2001

Jerry Minott, Saginaw Valley State University 

2000-2001 

Nick Bultema, Grand Valley State University (Baseball)

2001-2002 

Dan Aultman, Calvin College 

2001-2002 

Willie Thomas, Ferris State University 

2002-2003  

Willie Burrel, Ferris State University

Darin Kanouse, Lake Superior State University

Nick Predko, SI-Tanka University Huron  

Eddie Ward, Olivet College 

Carey Pohlman, Saginaw Valley State University (Baseball) 

2003-2004

Tom Poe, Davenport University 

Steve Tolsma, Tri-State University

Julius Vines, Ferris State University

2004-2005

Aaron Gowell, Elmhurst College 

Jim Booth, Grace Bible College

Paul Williams, Paul Quinn College